"I'm not SUPERstitious, but I am stitious."
I watched The Office and Earl last night. I haven't had a chance to see my other Thursday night favorites (ER and CSI) yet, but they're waiting on the DVR. My takes:
1. My Name is Earl was good, though not necessarily excellent. Sara says that she misses the original pace of the show, when Earl would cross one thing off of his list in each episode. I think I agree with her.
Nevertheless, the episode showed hints of brilliance.
The show's willingness to mess with the opening sequence (in a previous season, they did an episode where the opened each segment with a different character doing the opening monologue bit and announcing, "My name is Joy," or "My name is Darnell," or whatever, and last night, the show opened with, "My Name is Inmate 28301-016") is refreshing and funny. It's evidence of the irreverence that makes the show good.
Earl joining the white-supremacist and old-guy gangs was excellent. So was Randy showing up and asking questions off of flash cards. Randy as lovable moron is hilarious, mostly because Ethan Suplee is brilliant. I think the writers have to be careful not to take this too far... It's hard to believe that the guy doesn't know how to cross the street but he does know how to drive a car. I don't need this show to be über-realistic, but I do need to be able to maintain my suspension of disbelief.
The poster on the wall was a funny way to write Giovanni Ribisi off the series (for now, anyways... I guess he had other projects to work on), but I would have enjoyed it if they took the Shawshank Redemption joke a little further. Ribisi standing in a drainage ditch yelling at lightning would have been great, or at least Earl throwing a rock through the poster.
Joy calling Randy "big-headed hillbilly Linus" was great. So was her stained-glass Earl (Darnell: "It looks just like Earl would look if he were made of glass."). Jaime Pressly is great on the show, and she deserved her Emmy. I think it should be noted, however, that when she's given too much screen time on her own, Joy gets grating and annoying. Her comedic pairing with Darnell gets better and better as the show progresses. At this point, their contrast makes for perfection.
2. Things The Office got right:
- Including almost every character in the episode. We missed the gang at Dunder-Miff all summer, and getting to see everyone again was like coming home after a vacation. Creed got lines, Oscar got lines, Angela got her own plot line, Darryl and Pam are co-religionists, and the whole-ep revolved around Meredith. Each time we saw a character for the first time, my face lit up.
- Pam and Jim. They didn't make Pam-Jim the center of the episode, and they didn't play the kiss as this giant dramatic moment with exciting music and all that crap. Using Kevin to vocalize what's going through the audience's minds was brilliant. Making their characters respond to their kiss in instant replay was brilliant. Not messing with their flirtatious friendship while at work was brilliant. The subtlety of the whole thing was brilliant. Their relationship played as being sweet and innocent and beautiful without being nauseating. Brilliant.
- The perfect dose of Andy. Enough to get across that he's still the same old Andy, but not so much that you wanted to strangle him. The whole nipple gag was laugh-out-loud funny.
- Dwight and the cat. You know putting Angela's live cat in the freezer is exactly what Dwight Schroot would really do. Perfect.
- The entire race sequence. From the big check and the stripper nurse (and the T-shirts, which I expect to see on NBC.com any second now) and the pasta to Michael barfing, the whole 5k part of the episode had me cracking up. Andy drafting behind Kevin, the guys driving to get a drink then meeting up at the end, and Toby taking it all too seriously was all comedic genius. Toby's character is exceptionally written. On one hand, he's Michael's arch-enemy, the only voice of adult sanity at D-M. On the other hand, he has that small bit of Michael in him that pops out once in awhile, like when he was genuinely upset that he didn't get a robe, or when he took the race seriously.
That's all for now. Stay tuned for my thoughts on ER and CSI once I've had a chance to see 'em.